The Contest is now over. Please see the results page.
Comments posted by our Visitors
Submitted By
Buck 1
Buck 2
Daniel Prizio
4.5
6.5
Buck 1 his back doesn’t have much sag to it and his neck hasn’t quite gotten really big so you can still see a difference between neck and chest. Buck 2 is older buck starting to show age.
Robert Brenes
8.5
2.5
Fi
Tj Croft
3.5
6.5
?
george berube
3.5
2.5
size face rack
Neely
5.5
2.5
looking at their faces and gut
bryan dohn
4.5
3.5
just a hunch
Zayne Heckenlively
4.5
3.5
Looking at the stomach and the leg length proportionate to the body.
William Curlis
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 has the thick neck but not the sagging belly of a truly old deer. Deer two Still has a well defined neck to shoulder division and does not have the bib barreled chest yet.
Ryan herman
4.5
4.5
Because I’m right
Jon Peaster
4.5
3.5
Buck #1 seems to have a flat back and sagging belly, but his neck tapers a little more than I would expect for a 5.5+ year old whitetail. Buck 3 seems like a typical 3.5 year old with his body habitus
Keith Schalles
4.5
3.5
guess
Justin Brown
3.5
2.5
#1- showing signs of maturity, however not to full potential.
#2- seems small and thin,
Bill Berning berning
1.5
1.5
Body size depth
Jeremy Babiec
6.5
5.5
Just my opinion
Ramsey walenton
5.5
4.5
Looks
Stephen Houk
4.5
6.5
Buck 1- body size and rack proportion.
Buck 2- loss of muscling on hind limbs suggest potential decline
Nick E Ritacco
5.5
3.5
body size to leg length
Ian Correll
4.5
5.5
The first buck has a nice rack but back does not not sway. The deer will fill out more next year. The second buck was mature, started to have a little sway in his back and is a big bodied for NY.
Joe Fornaro
5.5
4.5
1 being Canada their bodies are bigger. I would guess older fot a different location. 2 he still has a race horse appearance
Kent Heppe
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 chased off Buck 2, therefore it is dominant
Reginald Johnson
3.5
2.5
Deer 1 , Thick neck area
Deer 2 , Small neck area
bob sevigny
5.5
7.5
observation
Rob Burkart
4.5
3.5
Body size. Buck 1 is big with a slight sway in the back and start of a pot belly.
Buck 2 has a body like a sleek race horse.
Jessie McCauley
7.5
4.5
Buck #1 is more thick and has darker fur buck #2 is smaller and lighter fur
William Guderley
3.5
4.5
I guessed.
brett LeBaron
4.5
2.5
BUCK 1 HAS A SLIGHTLY DEEPER CHEST BUT NOT QUIT FULLY MUTURE AND BUCK TWO IS NOT MATURE YET. LOOKS LIKE HE IS ALL LEGS.
K9
5.5
4.5
Both mature bcks
James Todd Guthrie
3.5
2.5
Location and facial features.
Kevin Scott
3.5
6.5
Based on region of country, body size (length), length of forehead to end of nose, and body. Buck #1 is yet to reach his prime, while Buck #2 is on the decline.
Jake Alberda
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 has a sagging belly, hind quarters appear much smaller than the chest/neck. Not much back sagging, no older than 4.5. Buck 2 appears younger, hind quarters are larger, chest larger than belly.
Jake Alberda
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 has a sagging belly, hind quarters appear much smaller than the chest/neck. Not much back sagging, no older than 4.5. Buck 2 appears younger, hind quarters are larger, chest larger than belly.
Bernard Buiting
4.5
3.5
Buck #1 has a low sagging belly and a thickness in his neck and head. Buck #2 is more slender and the antlers do not seem close to their potential size yet.
chad imig
4.5
3.5
1- Nice mass looks mature
2- Seems decent but young
Steve Platt
5.5
3.5
Buck 1: Thick neck, pot belly starting, back is not sagging that much, no loose skin below chin, very distinct sternum, roman nose starting
Buck 2: Skinny neck, narrow long body, no pot belly, sternum
Dennis Harrell
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 large belly and chest
Buck 2 slim large frame
Melissa Leeth
3.5
3.5
Buck 2 looks young while buck 1 looks to be around 3.5 4 years old
lance nogosek
3.5
7.5
genetics are different in the locales, buck #2 is on the down hill.
Scott Hare
6.5
3.5
Body of buck 1 is that of an older deer while body of deer 2 is of a younger deer.
Kasondra Suchocki
9.5
4.5
Buck 1’s belly is very saggy where as Buck 2 is more lean.
Caden Scott O’Neil
4.5
3.5
I Chose those ages because their legs still seem longer than what an older deer because most older deer’s legs look shorter but more body mass
Mark KAZMIERCZAZK
3.5
4.5
buck one's nose is short and Canadian bucks get real big as 4or5 year old's. the second buck has a long nose though he is a little thinner looks like an early, or preseason pic.
Paul Vice
3.5
2.5
Body on both deer suggest younger deer. Mass on buck #1 is decent, but not impressive. Not expecting much mass on buck #2 after velvet falls off. His movement pattern suggests a young buck.
Shaun
2.5
7.5
Buck1 is a young deer that would be getting toward showing more promise of bigger rack. Reasoning I’m saying 2.5 is no belly sag or drop in back at all. Buck2 to me appears to be older in the hips.
Shirl Valdez
2.5
3.5
Length of the antlers, neck thickness, leg size
Jason delpalazzo
3.5
3.5
#1 Body looks mature but lacks the mass in antlers , so I say 3.5 because it’s Saskatchewan and I expect those deer to have a bigger body anyway.
#2 looks to be your typical 3.5 year old
Lee Marks
4.5
3.5
Buck #2 doesn't have the stocky body of a fully mature buck. Buck #1 nose isn't as stocky and thick as a fully mature buck.
Joshua Pierson
5.5
4.5
Buck 1 has an obvious slanted back and prominent belly sag. Also, has some abnormal points indicative of an older deer. Buck 2 looks like a bit younger based on the night time vid
Jonathan Boehme
5.5
4.5
Buck #1 has a massive neck suggesting at least 4.5, and his hind quarters have filled out as well, likely 5.5. Buck #2 hasn’t swollen for the rut yet, but has a heavy body suggesting he is mature.
Blaine Sheppard
6.5
3.5
A huge body on deer #1 reminds me of other 6.5 year old bucks.
Deer 2 is younger with a thin body and a clear “indented notch” where his neck meets the chest. This deer will be phenomenal.
Jason Rose
4.5
3.5
Buck 1.... big, blocky body but don’t see a lot of age on him. Face looks younger . Also, very little tarsal staining for November rut .
Buck 2... late summer,done growing . Looks young
Jason Boyle
4.5
3.5
Body size
STEVE DAVIS
3.5
4.5
Just a guess
Charles Miller
5.5
3.5
Deer #1 has developed a very thick chest and has a lot of stomach drop, showing lots of white hair back to his flank. Buck #2 hasn’t filled out in the chest but his flank line is dropping.
Jacob Eidenschink
3.5
2.5
The neck size and skin dropage
John
2.5
3.5
Gut
richard d yeager
5.5
3.5
buck 1 antlers mass
buck 2 body sizes
darren pavis
3.5
3.5
neither deer looks short legged... lack of sag
Brian Rodrigue
4.5
3.5
Saskatchewan deer or naturally bigger yet this deer still does not have a sway back and big belly so I said he could be 4 1/2. Dear number two seems a bit younger because of body size and antler siz
KEVIN M SMITH
6.5
7.5
Just looks.
Bruce Schantz
3.5
4.5
Both bucks "seem" younger based on their appearance. Also to get a deer that size in NNY it would normally need to be at least 4.5.
mike d
4.5
3.5
buck one big neck, long nose. buck 2 has a small neck with small bases
David G Kaden
4.5
3.5
Both bucks Do not show the physical signs of older age class bucks. Buck 1 with the kickers and bigger neck seems older but not over 6.
JACOB GRIMSRUD
5.5
6.5
Wild Guess
John Balkurna
3.5
2.5
just a gus
Jason Gregg
4.5
3.5
#1 is bigger bodied and is starting to get a sagging stomach. #2 has a leaner look.
Brian Hickey
4.5
5.5
Buck 1 looks older in the first pic but in the second looks younger. He could be 3.5 but I don't believe he is over 4.5.
Buck two is more difficult. I'm going by rack size here.
Carson Cockrell
4.5
2.5
1 buck had a big neck and antlers at the base, the 2 buck looked younger at the neck and body
Eric Houston
4.5
3.5
based on body size and depth of chest and neck size
Ronald Kaiser
4.5
3.5
THE FIRST BUCK HAD MORE MASS IN THE ANTHLERS ALSO MORE BODT MASS.
Jonathon Peterson
4.5
2.5
First buck-big body, thick neck. Thick horns. Not much grey though.
Second buck- thin neck, smaller bodied.
Alan Kurrass
3.5
3.5
Head and body shape
Dwayne miller
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 has slightly swayed back and a full neck. Buck 2 doesn’t look fully developed just looks young
Dean Josephson
4.5
2.5
Buck #1 has a full neck and slightly sway back, buck #2 looks young and not fully developed
B. Powell
3.5
2.5
Buck one appears to be a mature deer in the first photo but the second shows less structure of the body that would make most people think he is younger.Buck two is long legged, small narrow neck that
Jeff carter
5.5
3.5
#1 very blocky
#2 skinny and longer body
zachary heeter
5.5
3.5
Big gut and large neck and chest. Buck #2 is still small in the chest
Brett Craver
2.5
3.5
Buck 1 had a narrow short nose, flatter belly and they grow fast in Sask.
Buck 2 had a longer face, not much time to look but seemed older
Hunter Martin
4.5
2.5
The first buck looks real thick, and slightly aged but still not that old, while the second buck is a lot skinnier and looks like an immature deer.
nick cauley
4.5
3.5
buck one, little noticeable difference from neck to from shoulder and pretty even body
buck two neck noticeably different to shoulder
Neal Finke
5.5
3.5
#1 big gut, thick neck prime age deer not over the hill
#2 Long legs racehorse look
CHRIS BULLINGTON
4.5
4.5
Region and nutrition make a big difference on these bucks. I think they may both be 4.5
Curtis Yoder
3.5
5.5
Buck one is videoed in the fall and has a neck that does not flow seamlessly from the body
Buck 2 is a summertime photo so the neck muscles are not yet bulging and has just a slight swayed back.
Leif Busby
4.5
9.5
Would have guessed the first at 4.5 but with his tarsal glands having no staining confidence is low.
2nd buck rack is too big for a young deer as his neck would suggest and he just looks old.
Jeremy Forbord
4.5
3.5
Mainly a wild guess as there's no imperial data to go off. Buck one looked older than buck two, but didn't look like a 5.5 year old to me.
Greg Yezierski
4.5
3.5
Just a guess
Stephen
3.5
4.5
Due to genetics and food; believe the Saskatchewan buck while bigger is actually younger. Age based on body size/shape primarily
Luke Wittman
3.5
2.5
Deer 1 has a nice big body but I'm thinking a SKA deer any older than 3.5 would have more mass and a thicker chest.
Deer #2 looks thick in velvet but that face is still a little snubby to be mature.
steve piskorowski
3.5
3.5
i dont have to tell you anything
Jeremie Frazier
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 has fully mature body with slight sag in belly and back. Good mass on rack. Buck 2 has straight back with undeveloped muscle in rear end and shoulders. Belly is full but not sagged from age
Jay Jackson
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 has a large body with the big belly and saggy back, buck 2 still has a loyt of growing yet both antler and body
Skip Farley
5.5
3.5
Body size and differences.
Curtis Yoder
3.5
5.5
Buck one is videoed in the fall and has a neck that does not flow seamlessly from the body
Buck 2 is a summertime photo so the neck muscles are not yet bulging and has just a slight swayed back.
bruce ROSCOE roscoe
4.5
3.5
Buck one has a lot of mass
Buck 2 looks younger
Phil Gardner
5.5
2.5
1. big neck sagging belly
2 no sag
Benjamin David Smith
3.5
3.5
Body size/shape and behavior with smaller buck for deer #1. Deer #2 rutting like it’s the last rut of his life and body size/shape.
Antonio Goncalves
4.5
3.5
Buck one seemed a bit sagging in the paunch.
Buck 2 less so
Justin Broughton
3.5
5.5
SWAG! Scientific Wild Ass Guess!
Joey Minvielle
4.5
5.5
just a guess
Tony Altenhofen
6.5
3.5
Body size
Steve Marsman
3.5
4.5
I based my guess on body size and horn mass on both deer.
Michael J. Bittner
4.5
3.5
just guessing
Dave Schiller
4.5
3.5
Buck 1-body configuration, more mature & filled out. Buck 2-earlier in year but leaner, not as old.
Caleb Phillips
4.5
3.5
Neither of the bucks show sagging if you look across their backs, tells me not older than 4.5
Duane Szymanowski
4.5
3.5
D
Lewis Walker
3.5
5.5
Guessing on the genetics
Rodney Duane Johnson
4.5
3.5
Has a larger neck
rack is dont have a lot of mas
Charles Hicks
6.5
3.5
#1) Nice mature looking body & head shape
#2) younger looking body & head shape
Henry William Fielding
3.5
4.5
Guesses
Ron Chavez
3.5
2.5
I based it on antler characteristics and body size and shape.
Andrew O'Brien
5.5
4.5
Guessing
Mark Kopp
4.5
3.5
Guessing
Mark Cyr
6.5
4.5
Gauging them both more on body than antler in this case. Antler helps but not everything.
Joe McFadden
6.5
4.5
Buck 1 potbelly narrow hips big shoulders double chin.
Buck 2 hard to tell due to time of year, but based on antler mass and shoulder size. Big chest/tight waist.
Jeff Allard
3.5
2.5
Antler base, neck shape, shoulder profile
Paul Wickingson
3.5
4.5
Guessing
Paul Wickingson
3.5
4.5
Guessing
Jeff goetz
5.5
3.5
Based on body shape and size
steve mackenzie
3.5
4.5
Sask buck can be bigger than a NY buck of the same age. In New York the second buck had to survive longer to get that big. IMHO
Jason Kosanke
5.5
3.5
Buck #1, thick neck, wide body, and shape of head, mature deer. Buck #2, based on body size, and leg length/body proportion, not as old as deer #1, antler development says at 3.5 to me.
Jim Gaskins
6.5
3.5
Buck 1 is heavily built, he has the body mass of a healthy truly adult male. Buck 2 is much more slender and youthful in appearance. His antlers and body don't have the obvious mass of Buck 1.
Greg Luchak
5.5
3.5
my best guess
Edward F Finn
4.5
2.5
Deer one has a healthy thick rack deer two is little smaller
DAVID ANDERSON
5.5
4.5
#1 back, belly sag. thick neck, short legs
#2 flat back/belly. long legs
Cord Gwennap
4.5
3.5
Body features of deer. Buck 1 is starting to sag in back. Buck 2 still has straight back
Derek grothen
3.5
4.5
First one is filled out no back sag second one has back sag
Bill Guiffredo
3.5
3.5
Both deer are the same age, but the Canadian deer has more bulk because of the location farther north.
Sean Power
4.5
4.5
Body size on both makes me think they're both mature but different genetics. Canadian deer are just bigger bodies than NY deer at same age.
Patrick Wensman
5.5
4.5
good size body on buck 1. still has ways to go on buck 2
Kevin
5.5
2.5
First buck is obviously mature. Sagging belly, large neck, graying face and wrinkled skin.
Second buck has large antlers but does not appear to be fully mature. No belly, slender neck and head.
Nick Duggan
4.5
7.5
Up and coming
On the way down
Glenn Nielsen
3.5
2.5
Stocky frame some droop in back, doesn't appear to be old buck 2 nice antlers but very slender looks young
Dale Beisner
4.5
3.5
buck 1 deep chest and belly. Buck 2 not as much but mature
robert l scarfo
4.5
5.5
just a guess they both look mature
Brian Miller
4.5
3.5
Tend to look slightly on the younger side
rich bossarelli
4.5
3.5
they both still look young to me
Mark Green
5.5
4.5
body shape suggest at least 5,5 on #1 #2appears to be slender in the hips so would suggest a year or so younger
Roger spiegeleire
6.5
3.5
Body shape identifies buck one as being much older
Mark Kurdys
4.5
6.5
No 1 shows dominant behavior, heavy body but not "horsey", No.2 nocturnal shot in velvet, 10 points but not tall, "horsey" head profile suggest a buck just past physical prime.
Matt Schlink
5.5
3.5
Saggy brisket on #1, but doesn't appear really old. Buck #2 hasn't filled out yet - looks young.
vic bergen
4.5
3.5
just a w.a.g. .....buck1 is a familiar site here in sask. not great genetics, body shape looks likely mature but not old. buck 2 has good antler,butt makes him look younger than old.
John Waight
5.5
3.5
Buck 1: Over all frame, belly and brisket size.
Buck 2: Frame, slender neck, tight flat belly
donald humphrey
4.5
2.5
going by belly line
Ken Hamil
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 saggy belly, buck two, tighter belly
Jim Byrne
3.5
2.5
Buck 2 is thin with not belly sag and not very big in the neck
Buck 1 is starting to get a sag and very think in the chest
Alan Hamil
5.5
3.5
Deer
jerry hurst
6.5
5.5
body size
Daniel ONeal
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 large saggy neck. stumpy face.
Buck 2 Slender long neck.
Jason PeringtonJ
6.5
3.5
Buck 1 has the obvious belly hump so you would assume older than 4.5. Buck number 2 looks pretty streamlined but taller so I would guess 2.5 to 3.5.
john mullin
5.5
3.5
Size of the body.
jesse karpinski
4.5
5.5
Buck has full neck and body. Not too old in the face. Buck 2 has older face
Cory Degen
6.5
4.5
#1 Bigger bodied, dominant buck
Joe Stolze
4.5
7.5
Buck 1- straight along the top of the back, no droop in the abdomen, looks to be a younger, mature buck. Buck 2- Round abdomen, coat thinning very square jaw, looks to be an older buck.
Gary Gross
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 - flat back, rear and front quarters about equal size, full face, but no excessive roman nose. Buck 2, narrow face, small shoulders.
Skiop Bogdan
4.5
3.5
Rack mass and body structure
Greg koehl
1.5
2.5
I'm just guessing
Jeremy McKean
6.5
4.5
Thick neck and grey face #1.
Ronald C Arbach
2.5
7.5
looking at the body
Vito D'Aiuto
3.5
5.5
Both have great muscle mass.#1 has a young face,#2 slight belly sag
Joseph Blaylock
3.5
1.5
#1 shoulders not taller than the rump
RAY CERNANSKY
6.5
3.5
BODY SIZE AND STATURE FOR 1, YOUNG LOOK FOR 2
Scott VandeVoort
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 is thick and buck 2 seems to be smaller.
John Bacon
6.5
4.5
Looked at body lines as well as brisket. Also the face particularly the shape of the nose.
Mike Collins
3.5
4.5
Just a guess from what I see in the Midwest.
Bill
4.5
6.5
Location had the most to do with my guess.
Pat
4.5
2.5
No rational, just a wild guess.
Eric Farrer
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 is a little more swayback, chest is fuller
Jim
4.5
3.5
Buck #1 had a dropping under belly. Buck #2 looked like most 3.5yr bucks I have seen
Richard Reeves
3.5
1.5
big body, but not old , mature whitetail. #2 slender body , nice rack but not a mature deer
bill moody
6.5
2.5
#1 Body looks 5 but movement looks older.
#2 Just looks slender
Anthony Demski
4.5
3.5
Buck one has a paunch. I believe this starts around 4.. Buck two just looks younger.
Christian Haskett
4.5
2.5
1-body full, but back still straight
2. Neck not filling out body at the shoulders yet
GARY REED
5.5
3.5
LOOKS
peter alexander
3.5
2.5
bk 1 pick 1 taken during rut, body mass and antler development good but no roman nose yet. bk 2 still looks like a young deer
jeff fehrenbach
4.5
2.5
belly ,stickers no belly, short tines thin horns
Carson Schilling
4.5
4.5
Wild ass guess. Very difficult to age by pics alone without something to compare them to, especially not being familiar with these regions.
Dale M Humble SR
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 is a mature animal. He is stocky, slight belly sag but has not yet developed the roman nose or grey face. he also has antler mass. Buck 2 is young. Has no antler mass, & a race horse look
James Kerschbaum
4.5
3.5
#1's neck fills in completely down to his brisket and has a slight belly on him. #2's neck is not filled out down to his chest and his head has a younger look to it.
Alan McRae
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 has deep girth and large hams and shoulders. His neck skin is saggy indicating his advanced age. His back sways as well also indicating his advanced age. Buck 2 doesn't have these charact.
James Pinheiro
4.5
3.5
Body structure, buck 1 plump and filled out. Buck 2 skinny and visible skeletal structures
NORMAN PARKS
5.5
4.5
Body characteristics
Christian bohrnsen
4.5
2.5
The First Buck has become dominate and his coloring says that he is an older butck his brisket is full.
Buck 2 is very young and has a great rack but his neck and brisket have not developed.
Gene Rhodes
2.5
4.5
Way bigger deer in Canada so a 2.5 looks older here.
2nd deer is a great new york buck. lots of pressure so older deer are few and far.
alan sinnett
5.5
3.5
body size and shape
Ryan Hess
2.5
4.5
Just know
Mike G
6.5
4.5
Wild A$$ guess.
Jim Higgins
4.5
2.5
1) stubby legs and blocky body
2) skinny body frame
Angela Grove
7.5
4.5
I think the first buck is 7.5 because he is big and has confidence. I think the second one is 4.5 because he is smaller.
Buck #1 appears to have more of a Roman nose but is lacking the sway back that comes with age.
Andy Mccormick
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 is a big solid bodied deer with a sagging belly line.
Buck2 is a smaller deer with a younger looking face and tight belly line
Jennifer
4.5
2.5
Angle of back to shoulder; tummy sag; neck thickness
Ed Wurmb
3.5
2.5
SWAG
Dave Ruckle
3.5
3.5
Sask grows them large to survive winter- not too deep in the chest, or sway backed yet. NY buck- same look, just smaller framed.
David Summers
4.5
2.5
Buck1: body mass development, neck girth to body.
Buck2: immature muscle development, spindle legs and rear. Thinner face and narrow rack development...signs of an adolescent.
Gary Hammett
5.5
3.5
Buck #1appears to be a mature buck but not excessively old with the pot belly. He does have a full chest and neck. Buck #2 lacks the the filled out chest and neck.
Josh DeBolt
4.5
3.5
Both bucks appear mature with a beginning of a big brisket area, but back lines are very straight and the bellies aren't very saggy, so I wouldn't go so far as to say they're 5 or older yet...
Armand Tetreault
5.5
4.5
body shape
Adam Ludwin
4.5
2.5
Buck one pretty thick neck, belly sag,pretty proportional good antler growth! Buck 2 nice antler growth but skinny neck legs still look long compared to body
Don Carlson
7.5
2.5
Body size, antler mass
Henry Laupan
5.5
2.5
Looked mostly at the body , pot belly ,heavy . The swollen neck might mean he's in the rut though. Deer one is tall and lean
Paul Tomasello
5.5
4.5
body size, wrinkled kneck buck 1.
Harold Edward Coates
4.5
2.5
Looking at his body tells it all. Yes this second deer is young
Jacob Nisley
4.5
2.5
Buck #2 just has a pretty streamlined body to be an old deer.
james short
3.5
3.5
Just For fun
Richard Barnes
5.5
2.5
Buck #1 mature and solid
#2 a juvenile
Richard Barnes
5.5
2.5
Buck #1 mature and solid
#2 a juvenile
Dennis Stott
3.5
7.5
Buck one short body,short nose, eating well still has good teeth, thin bases, rack even with ear width. Buck two, long body, thin due to lack of teeth, thick bases , rack width outside of ears.
Albert Klenk
5.5
3.5
Buck one white around mouth and larger base by brow-tine buck two underdeveloped base at base of antlers and he is a little smaller in mass .
bob stephenson
5.5
2.5
rack nose body #1 mature #2 lean body long nose
Nathan Guy
5.5
3.5
///
Scott Baker
5.5
3.5
Good guess
Christian coté
6.5
3.5
First buck the size of the neck definitely à mature
2 buck Nice horn but deer is small
Aaron Nielsen
5.5
3.5
Buck one is large bodied but I think he is only 5.5. buck two has large rack buy I think he is only a 3.5, his body is young.
Christopher Gates
5.5
3.5
head and body structure.
Jason K Beall
6.5
4.5
The first seems fully mature but not aged, confident and dominant. Puts him in the 5-7yr range.
The second looks younger, not yet a full body, but grown enough to almost be there. 3-4yrs
Raymond Porzio
5.5
3.5
Buck No. 1 has a blocky appearance and a deep chest and deep belly characteristics of a 4.5 to 6.5 year old so I will guess 5.5. Buck No. 2 is not quite as blocky and has a leaner appearance.
Dave Stone
5.5
4.5
Buck 1 has the body of an older deer. Deer 2, based on the area, not anything specific, just a guess
Ross Gaddy
7.5
3.5
The first buck has saggy skin under his chin and gray on his face. Also his legs look stumpier for his body, than it would on a younger deer. Summer deer are harder to age. I based my guess on body.
Stephen fox
3.5
2.5
1 is looking strong but has not hit his stride looks good chest but not quite a 4 yr old
2 just looks thin in his chest and his slope from back to front says young deer to me
Justin Taddey
5.5
3.5
Guessing by the neck and saggy belly on the 1st buck. The second buck just looks like a younger deer.
Chris Keele
4.5
5.5
Based on width and mass
MILTON ARMITAGE
5.5
3.5
#1heavy body/heavy shoulders
# 2 long body/no mass
Ron Fine
4.5
3.5
Just going by body size. Its just a guess.
Howie Owens
4.5
2.5
Big body & large frame, mature rack. #2
Small rack, thinner frame, smaller head
Michael Doherty
5.5
3.5
Buck 1: antler mass, body build
Buck 2: lighter body, head
Alan McGraw
5.5
3.5
Buck one looks mature, but not ancient. Pronounced stomach. Some triangulation to head. Stocky body with bigger chest. Larger body in relation to the other deer. Deer 2 has flat stomach, thinner,
Jack rice
2.5
4.5
Years of sitting in a tree stand.
Tony Fenetz
3.5
4.5
Buck1 very healthy but does not have the belly like buck 2
Chris Hermann
6.5
2.5
Body size and locations
Kristin
3.5
2.5
Body size on 2, brow ridge on 1
Duane Armitage
6.5
2.5
size
Lamar Perry
4.5
2.5
Buck one looks mature bot the legs are a little long and there is no sway in the back. Buck two is just a typical lean and long two year old with a nice rack.
Kenneth Danklefs
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 has no droopy skin even though his body is thick. Facial features look too young to be older. Buck 2 is lean with narrow nose.
Mike Ose
4.5
3.5
#1 top of back to belly measure (girth)
#2 Shape of head and girth
CACHE Myers
5.5
4.5
1st: non typical, sinked back and belly, rough antlers big breast
2nd Striaght back, smaller rack, great genetics, would be Huge if left longer
Adam Matalavage
4.5
3.5
Purely a guesstimate
CACHE Myers
5.5
4.5
1st: non typical, sinked back and belly, rough antlers big breast
2nd Striaght back, smaller rack, great genetics, would be Huge if left longer
John Ford
3.5
3.5
Full bodied but no sag under chin and no tarsal staining. No belly sag. Neither buck has that stiff gate or knock kneed walk to them.
John Harmonson
7.5
10.5
1# one was fat telling be he still had his teeth . Moved like an older buck with slight greying. #2 older buck skinny with plenty of food, ratty hide.
Ben Corvin
3.5
2.5
Deer 1 has 3 year old body almost filled out body.
Deer 2 has 2 year old body slim and trim
John Harmonson
10.5
1.5
movements and eyes seemed like an old buck along with the grey area on the head.
Billy Cockrell
4.5
3.5
I first thought #1 was older, but his body didn’t have a sway to it. #1 had smallish body. So I don’t think he was even what I guest him to be.
Michael Perrault
4.5
2.5
Buck 1: Large neck & body but not quite deep enough in the chest & belly to be much older.
Buck 2: Nice rack but thin neck & hips put him in this category.
Paul D. Harwood
7.5
5.5
Looking at body, 7 chest plus length of both bucks.
Roy. Seidl
2.5
3.5
Rack size and snout coloration
Anita Scott
5.5
3.5
#1 shorter legs pot belly sway back.
#2 long legs, lean
Kraig Wiser
4.5
1.5
buck #1 is blockier than #2 which looks younger to me
Joseph Beyor
6.5
4.5
body size
David Scott
4.5
3.5
Body size and shape
Don Meyer
3.5
2.5
Buck #1 looked older and appears to have some grey around the eyes buck#2 from New York looked thin and the antlers weren't thick yet and he appears much younger
Joe Schmaedick
4.5
6.5
Buck 1 is large bodied but still sleek and "fit" looking without some of the sagging of older deer.
Buck 2 is starting to show older age. Could be anything between 5.5 and 8.5 IMO.
Lou Budica
7.5
4.5
Buck # 1 looks like a less aggressive older deer .Buck #2 more alert to noise and still screamish to sounds .
Charlie Henke
5.5
3.5
1st buck boxy body, 2nd buck nice rack but body not filled out yet
Tucker LaForce
3.5
5.5
The body size and brisket drop lead me to believe this deer is older also much more dominant (1)
Small lean neck
Dave Guggenbiller
4.5
3.5
1 heavy neck, belly fat but not saggy. 2 long leaner , still young but great genes
Chris moser
4.5
5.5
Deer 1 is a northern deer that will be much larger. 2 is a eastern buck and pretty large. Could be 6.5 years.
George
5.5
3.5
Backs straight on both. Gray faces. #1 belly little sager than #2. #1 shorter nose than #2. #1 is first of rut and #2 rut is over.
Ted Amedro
5.5
3.5
Deer one has the “old look to him. Thick neck might be deceiving do th the rut.
Deer two just looks young but would place him at 3 1/2
Ryan m Olson
4.5
5.5
1.big loose brisket, and sagging belly and back.
2. tight body, straight back, very clean looking fur and head.
Randy Doyle
5.5
3.5
size of body compared to leg lenght
Alexander Czajka
4.5
2.5
I look at belly and head size
Brandon J Wise
4.5
3.5
Nose/face length. Belly/back sag.
Ron Avery
4.5
3.5
Canadian buck has slight paunch/ fairly heavy antlers bigger body than most of the three year olds killed in Saskatchewan.
NY buck lives in farm country. Younger looking frame large w/ less mass.
dave puetz
4.5
6.5
just a guess
David Huennekens
5.5
4.5
No. 1 buck has bigger body than no. 2 buck, looks older
Chuck rappenecker
3.5
2.5
Buck one was very calm when confronting the younger buck but his back was still a little level rather than swayed. Buck two was on public land and running around day and night
Troy a Najarian
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 has depth of shoulder and a long snout but still smooth body not blocky
Buck two is very slender through the neck and shoulders
Aubrey Jackson
5.5
4.5
Simply basing my guess on known 7yr old buck's antlers.
Michael Witthuhn
10.5
3.5
bases muzzles and necks
Steve Blackmon
2.5
3.5
Back
Steve Converse
5.5
2.5
Buck 1 is bulky, belly is straight from chest to back legs (almost a paunch, lol) and a large "roman" nose. Buck 2 almost looks like a doe with antlers. Slim and with that taper from chest to legs.
Jack chellew
5.5
4.5
#1 potbelly and neck and brisket equal.
#2 lean back straight
BRian hyde
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 not much of Roman nose or saggy belly, sasakaawan buck so thick coat
Buck 2 no Roman nose and almost twin to buck I shot one year and was 2.5
George Robson
6.5
3.5
Body shapes faces
Scott Silvers
4.5
6.5
Buck #1 looks like good gene pool. Buck #2 has nose of an older deer.
Marshall Holdeman
4.5
6.5
Body condition and location
Cary Hawkins
5.5
3.5
just a guess, with out the teeth and a Biologist I can only say I would kill either and be very happy+†+
Dale Stouffer
6.5
4.5
Body size, low belly, shoulder width
Bill Krause
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 looks more mature and full frame rack. Buck even through larger rack than 1, doesn't look mature.
STEPHEN KREMP
5.5
3.5
Based on body and head shape.
David C Jones
4.5
6.5
body size
joe sivits
3.5
2.5
antler size and mass
matt kanouse
3.5
3.5
Body shape and geography.
David Stiles
4.5
1.5
He is going to get bigger.
Ron Nail
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 is mature but just starting to show that in antler but also in body build.
Buck 2 still has alot of growth to go for antler and body.
Zach Welch
4.5
6.5
The swooping belly and athletic build to deer #1 tell me he is most likely 4.5 years old. For buck #2, I said 6.5 because of the short tines, and more weathered looking body.
Fred allen
3.5
5.5
Buck one young buck yet. Buck two old word down
Mike stone
4.5
3.5
Buck number 1 based on body size, belly, rack, area
Buck number 2 based on body size, belly, rack, area
Mark Jorrey
6.5
2.5
#1 - Fat brisket and falling midsection. #2 - Slender
Terry Picard
4.5
3.5
Just a guess based on size and characteristics.
Michael Ichimura
3.5
2.5
Back structure & forehead
Christopher Daley
3.5
3.5
I believe both bucks are 3.5. the difference in body size is due location and habitat.
George Flournoy
4.5
2.5
Buck one is a Northern Sask, Huge body deer but not yet 5 years oldDeer #2 is a very young buck slim neck and body most likley his second set of horns.
peter crowningshield
2.5
4.5
Saskatchewan has big young deer while NY takes time for them to grow if they live that long.
Steven Svitak
5.5
3.5
neck, belly, normally what they age around here
Brian Albano
4.5
3.5
body size and facial features
Dylan J Smith
3.5
3.5
I feel that the Saskatchewan buck has the beefed up bull look, but is also built differently to survive up their. Both bucks have that flat back and in their prime look to me. Just guess w/o history.
Ramie Walton
5.5
4.5
buck one has a slight paunch and his face is starting to fill out. Buck two is still thin in the stomachand has a thin face. also he is in velvet which makes his rack look heavier.
james holland
3.5
5.5
Buck one is in rut and looks bigger but his short nose and shorter body reveal that He is younger than Buck 2. Buck two has a longer body and nose but lacks the rut size and winter coat of buck 1.
Robert Pembleton
4.5
3.5
Guess
Garvin Gibbins
2.5
1.5
Both deer look young.
Terry R Allee
4.5
2.5
Body size going from neck to body
Darin mcalister
3.5
3.5
Saskatchewan deer shows signs of being dominant over other deer. Lacking in mass and has body size . New York deer in fall and hasn’t put on weight yet.
Gary Yerina
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 is starting to get sagging in the brisket area. Not quit an old man but getting there.
Buck 2 is streamlined, straight across the back , no sagging in the belly area.
John Ivanisin
4.5
2.5
Buck #1 obviously bigger but not an old man. Buck #2 will be a great deer one day when he matures
Michael Yacopino
4.5
3.5
The Saskatchewan bucks always have massive bodies and are a different breed of whitetail. He looks fit and O didnt see any swale in his back or aged looking face.The NY buck has great genetics young
Michael Yacopino
4.5
3.5
The Saskatchewan bucks always have massive bodies and are a different breed of whitetail. He looks fit and O didnt see any scale in his back or aged looking face.The NY buck has great genetics young
John J Lukach
5.5
2.5
Buck #1 has wide neck and huge shoulders with belly sag #2 narrow neck and small shoulder with straight back and slim belly
Chad Wactor
3.5
4.5
Buck 1 is heavy bodied but looked young in the face. Buck 2 just has an older look to him
Hayden Odhner
4.5
2.5
Deer 1 large barrel chest, shortened nose
Deer 2 lean and lanky straight line belly sharp nose
David Gilbert
3.5
8.5
#1 looks older than he is based on where he lives. #2 looks like he is on the back side of a good life, starting to loose mass
neal lightle
7.5
4.5
Buck 1 looks like he's regressing and the calcium deficiencies in his diet are starting to show in the way he walks. Buck 2 looks like a young buck who has good genetics but lacks beam width / body #
Travis John schauer
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 no pot belly just a solid Canadian rut buck
Buck 2 hard to tell age early in the year pre rut when he is not filled out. Wouldn’t surprise me if he was acouple years older than my guess
Tod Becker
5.5
3.5
#1 blocky deer with heavy antler mass
#2 looks like he has a lot of room to grow in the body and antlers
Gary Rathman
5.5
3.5
Buck # 1 has the body charicteristics that one would associate with a mature Whitetail Buck, ie, Roman nose,full muscled shoulders and hind quarters ,slight sway back, belly. #2 needs to mature bodily
Carl Casper
4.5
5.5
Best guess based on pictures.
david e. walker
5.5
2.5
buck #1
no obvious transition between brisket and neck. short face, slightly sway back.
buck #2
obvious transition between brisket and neck. ganigly and youthful appearance, long face.
richard hanson
4.5
3.5
guessing
Jon Krecklau
6.5
2.5
Just a feeling
Jhawn Saul
4.5
3.5
Based on body proportions and respective geographic locations
Terry Truett
4.5
3.5
1st Buck neck was almost level with his body making it look like all 1 plus he had a lil belly sag. 2nd buck neck was still thin, long & belly didn't have the old man pot belly just MHO needs time
Chris Ingalls
4.5
3.5
Body frame, rack mass and facial structure.
Joe Thompson
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 looks young not a big belly and no swayed back
Jake Ensign
6.5
5.5
I usually base age estimates on belly sag, front shoulder development, presence of graying, and overall body morphology.
Perry Nichols
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 has a narrow face, but starting to fill out with weight showing some belly but needs a couple more years to finish.
Buck 2 has nice antler growth, but is very thin like a younger deer.
Joseph M Horty
4.5
2.5
1) low belly his body was not straight like the second BUCK
David Pfeiffer
5.5
4.5
Body build
Okey livingston
2.5
1.5
Not sure
Chuck Forbes
4.5
2.5
Based on body size and size of the rack.....
Christopher T. Wert
3.5
2.5
guest
Michael Gruber
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 just looks like a 4.5 year old nice size body but the rack doesnt look like hes reached his prime yet. Buck 2 id say 3.5 because its got a smaller body and neck but rack appears biggerthanatow
Rich Reinert
4.5
4.5
Back line, body mass and posturing on 1, and body mass , antler development, attitude & overall movements on 2.
Chip Pletcher
4.5
3.5
#1 bigger more dominate
#2 slim looking body
Dave Echuk
4.5
2.5
Body size and neck circumference
Justin Staley
3.5
5.5
Just guessing
Tim Zimmerman
3.5
3.5
No mass
Tim Duncan
3.5
4.5
Just looking at the age in there face
Eric Chaisson
4.5
5.5
no time
Mikel Hart
5.5
7.5
Thickness of the rack. The muscle tone.
Randy Koopmann
4.5
2.5
#1 mature buck, heavy neck could be older, color of hair (gray) unk.
#2. Young deer, good genes, body development not there, legs, neck, belly.
Todd A Simmons
5.5
4.5
Buck #1 looks more filled out and muscular than buck number 2.
mike mitchell
3.5
5.5
don't know for sure
Lydia Hopper
4.5
2.5
Deer 1 heavy chest
Deer 2 long legs tapered belly
Lydia Hopper
4.5
2.5
Deer 1 heavy chest
Deer 2 long legs tapered belly
Clark Weeks
4.5
3.5
Size of body.
Drew Mulherin
3.5
3.5
Neck size and body shape
Allen Rebman
4.5
6.5
#1 Dominate Buck
#2 Looks old and going
down hill
Jason Toews
4.5
3.5
Buck one it’s starting to fill out, strong shoulders, slight potbelly, but his face still looks young. But number two, is slim and still doeish looking.
Josh Eicher
4.5
3.5
Deer 1 - large body deer but lacking the sagging be older than 4.5
Deer 2 - still developing his frame, so 3.5
Rob Lange
3.5
2.5
Just a guess as a hunter
Erik Bailey
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 was mature, but lacked the angles & "character in both face & body that develop in older bucks. Buck 2 had great antlers, but smooth body & skinny neck say he is young.
Greg Terrell
4.5
2.5
Big belly, but no swayback in buck one. That area deer bodies tend to be bigger, so rack looks smaller than it is. Buck two thin and athletic.
Brian W Riley
4.5
2.5
#1 has fully developed shoulders and chest with the beginnings of a dropped belly and big roman nose. #2 skeleton is still growing, no belly, no roman nose.
Kurt Knapp
5.5
1.5
Thick neck and body, sagging belly
Ronnie Everett
2.5
4.5
Looked at alot of deer
Robert Coleman
3.5
2.5
First deer was a big buck, but they grow big that far north. Second buck it was the brow tines,
Chris Kmiec
4.5
3.5
Thick body but not sway backed or pot bellied on #1...short snoot and thin body for #2.
Logan Hancock
4.5
4.5
Just a hunch.
Tim
5.5
3.5
Private land, graying around eyes and snout, spine (flat-swayback)
Bob Russo
3.5
4.5
Body mass
Gregory Lang
4.5
3.5
Grown of antler points and brow tines where the deciding factors in my guesses
Brad Smith
6.5
3.5
Overall body size compared to neck.
Mark Reszczynski
7.5
4.5
Body on buck 1 is bigger and face shows grey.
buck 2 body thin
NORBERT MARTIN
3.5
4.5
looking at the face and body size
Dellwyn Elkins Sr. ?????
4.5
3.5
Gut feeling
Ryan Athey
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 - blocky body, but not sagging belly, young looking face
Buck 2 - lean body, not much mass
Nicholas Martin
3.5
2.5
Not very much mass on the first buck. Second buck seems to be fairly young.
Craig doll
3.5
7.5
Skinny frame
Larry Hudson
4.5
6.5
Buck 1 antler size indicate to me he’s about 4 1/2. Buck 2 years old buck larger higher rack and size 6 1/2
(Retired)SFC Ivan Baros Sr
4.5
5.5
Thickness of neck. Body mass, number of tines, movement, color
Craig doll
3.5
1.5
Deer is healthy and does not have a long nose
Craig Clendenin
3.5
3.5
Though big bodied, the stomach and nose don’t show significant age. Thick horns is more customary on younger Canadian bucks than Texas white tails that I’m used to.
james l Campbell
4.5
3.5
Sask. buck is bigger than he looks
robert vaillancourt
4.5
3.5
buck 1 started showing a more bigger body. and buck 2 looked to be well feed and no bigger body
JT
5.5
3.5
#1 thick all around neck and brisket & wide in the back
#2 thin neck, body bigger than a typical 2 year old. not done growing yet
Daniel Prizio
4.5
6.5
Buck 1 his back doesn’t have much sag to it and his neck hasn’t quite gotten really big so you can still see a difference between neck and chest. Buck 2 is older buck starting to show age.
Nathan Bednar
4.5
3.5
No expert just going with antler and body size for both deer
Don
5.5
3.5
#1 has big bodies and big neck and belly saggy, #2 has toned muscle, the neck and chest are tighter.
Jacob Miller
6.5
2.5
Buck 1) Thick neck, sagging belly, & a swayed back. Buck 2) Thin neck (even given that he' still in velvet), spindly antlers even though he has a lot of points, and long legs indicating youth
EDWARD J AYERS
6.5
4.5
Antler points put them a little higher in age but belly and neck size tell a lot. Buck 1 has some age but not real old yet. He's been around a little which shows with his dominance in the video.
David Schucknecht
6.5
2.5
Buck 1 slight sway back ,bell not hight and tight. Loose skin on neck.
Buck 2 no big development in shoulders ,rear end looks high,long legs.
Curtis Clark
4.5
7.5
Buck 1 has a rectangle body with no neck sag. Thick neck but antlers don't have a lot of character or mass.
Buck #2 rectangle body with neck sag. Antler look as they might be going down hill
Hans Ellefson
3.5
2.5
1 has a more pronounced dip in his back, I wanted to say 3 years old but couldn't
James Williams
5.5
2.5
1. Older buck with body mass that makes his legs look short. Wrinkles on his neck indicate at least a 5 1/2 YO.
2)I am going with 2 1/2 due to his lean body and long legs, skinny neck
gary vermilyea
7.5
4.5
posture , antlers , experince
GARRY BRENT KRANTZ
7.5
3.5
Uneducated Guess.
tony nienas
4.5
4.5
that is what I think
Eric Anderson
5.5
4.5
I first buck looks a little older with the swayed belly starting. I think he may be 6.5 but being from Saskatchewan I am going with 5.5.
Harold Littlejohn
4.5
4.5
body shape of a mature deer but not old an old deer
Allen Kekel
3.5
2.5
Book number one is on private land in Saskatchewan which is known to grow big deer he doesn't have much of a belly for that area and his backbone is pretty straight still Buck number 2 is sqrawny
David Coons
4.5
3.5
#1 much bigger body. #2 smaller and not as old looking.
Sidney Lopez
4.5
2.5
Body build-facial features
WILLIAM SPICER
4.5
1.5
Because of the stickers and it's mass and eighth of its times plus the way his nose looked.
WILLIAM SPICER
4.5
1.5
Because of the stickers and it's mass and eighth of its times plus the way his nose looked.
Mike Lanum
3.5
3.5
Big bodied, but no sage in the back and face is slim on no. 1. Just a guess because of size in general.
WILLIAM SPICER
4.5
1.5
Because of the stickers and it's mass and eighth of its times plus the way his nose looked.
David Knoblauch
4.5
4.5
I believe both bucks to be the same age. Canadian deer tend to be larger, giving them the appearance of being older.
Eric J STACK
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 is of medium build for a Saskatchewan buck leading me to believe he is a few years away from being mature..
Buck 2 just appears to be a 2.5 yr old
Richard Hewitt
3.5
2.5
I think buck 2 could be 2 1/2 or 7 1/2 based on size. Buck 1 looked mature. But younger
Frank Shiflet
4.5
5.5
1st looks to be in prime and the second looks to be on the down side
Dennis VanBuren
6.5
4.5
Buck one seems to have a little sag to his belly- Back is still pretty straight so I would guess 6.5 --- Buck Two is Very lean and mean just entering prime so guessed 4.5
jack Petropoulos
4.5
5.5
SWAG:
#1 is an obvious stud probably from a well fed area likely promoting good fast growth so I am guessing on the younger side of the two. #2 showed very thick frames so giving him another year.
Dave Krause
4.5
3.5
base girth for #1.
Zack Anthony
3.5
3.5
#1 mature frame but medium neck, belly sag, and not old looking face.
#2 under developed frame in a region of under developed frames. Older looking belly, summer neck/face.
Bob
4.5
2.5
Just into its prime, deer one shows a slight sag to the belly, a longer face and bigger chest. Deer two is young, no sag, short nose, small chest.
Troy Morgado
5.5
3.5
Based off visual appearance
Michael B Santos
5.5
3.5
Body size on buck 1 is biger. Nice anylers on buck 2 but neck and body size are not there.
Todd VerStrate
3.5
2.5
Buck #1 Starting to fill out. Buck #2 Still a young slim deer.
Justin Fisher
2.5
2.5
Both looked like they were still maturing and not in decline
Bill Manger
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 getting a little thick around the middle and nose looks shorter and more rounded toward the end. Buck 2 still skinny and no belly drop yet and nose is long and slim
STEVE PIGNATARO
5.5
3.5
big body and stomach hanging # 2 deer don't get to be much older than 3.5 in new York
Mike Sample
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 has some age but is lacking the shortened looking face and is missing the sagged back and belly of an older deer. Buck 2 just looks young in the body and face so isn't aged older than 2.5.
Dennis Kluthe
4.5
3.5
#1 Big body, brisket hangs low, pot belly. #2 Sleek looking, neck transitions into brisket smoothly.
Michael James
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 still has a stream line body. Buck 2 looks like a die with antlers.
ken skibinski
5.5
3.5
Body sizes, belly, general knowledge of deer; SWAG! :)
Dale Smith
5.5
3.5
#1 full body #2 slim still young
Timothy M Reeser
6.5
3.5
Bucks faces, size of deer and chest as well as coloring.
Bronly Morningstar
4.5
3.5
Educated guess.
Gustav Ortwein
3.5
2.5
Neck size
ALAN MCDONALD
5.5
3.5
Buck #! square body drooped belly.
Buck #2 Still slender looking not blocky at all.
james slomian
5.5
3.5
buck one just looks dominate and aged , lots of extra weight.
buck two looks more lean, seems more agile
Hunter Brunk
4.5
3.5
The belly looks filled out on the first buck but i would expect the neck and brisket to be filled out more if it were any older. And they are just bigger up there. The second one roamed typical of a 3
Giles Turgeon
4.5
3.5
Smaller body, not heavy horned yet, number 2, no body size
Doug Yuds
5.5
7.5
#1 in his prime, firm muscle mass, large head. #2 muscles in shoulders and legs appear weak.
Howard L Roe
4.5
2.5
BUCK 1 BODY SIZE AND AGGRESSIVENESS. BUCK 2 MUSCULATURE NOT FILLED OUT.
Dale Smith
4.5
3.5
Not alot of mass
Dale Smith
4.5
1.5
Not alot of mass
Tommy Crawford
5.5
3.5
Mainly looking at their chests is my reason for the guesses.
Peter Sacco
3.5
4.5
2nd buck has a little more mass in his body than the first buck
herman Hatchett jr
4.5
2.5
the Neck on deer 1 is big his body is a little small # 2 is little Neck and Body
Ed West
4.5
2.5
#1 has a thicker body and legs look shorter.
#2 still looks young. Thin, long legs.
charles bowen
5.5
4.5
head and back and stomach evaluation. Photos do not allow for proper evaluation
Douglas Allen
6.5
3.5
#1 mature filled out body. #2 not full bodied yet, but very well fed with great development.
Michael Smith
5.5
2.5
Buck #1 looks filled out more than Buck #2. His body has more mass and his face is more mature. Buck #2 looks younger and once filled out will be a great deer!
kevin
7.5
1.5
I performed a morphometric analysis... which is the correct way to age when teeth are not available.
James Casto Jr
4.5
3.5
location
Eddie sells
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 has a filled out body. Big neck big chest sagging belly looks mature. Buck 2 has a smaller body legs look long chest doesnt look as filled out neck size hard to tell anything due to it being su
Bruce Rohdeburg
2.5
4.5
Canadian deer have larger body mass plus you can feed them. NY deer no point restrictions if it brown it is down.
julio Basas
5.5
2.5
1st buck has very thick neck, pot belly and wide shoulders
2nd buck seems young, slender and not yet filled out.
Travis Brown
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 is still not fully matured even high and fairly wide when this guy hits 4,5,6,or 7 years old he’ll be a true monster. Buck #2 very young deer with good genetics with old age he could be a real
Christopher Duda
3.5
2.5
Protruding chest, slight gut sag, filled out haunches, stout face
Second buck doesn’t look filled in yet. Less chest and gut, but probably older than a year and a half
Vince Luce
5.5
3.5
Buck #1 has a saggy stomach, deep chest and graying on his face especially above his nose and between his eyes. Buck #2 has great antler quality but still has a tightness in his chest and brisket.
Steven Messler
4.5
3.5
Body on buck 1 is very filled out indicating a mature buck. Buck is not a full and indicates a adolescent buck.
scott Coons
5.5
2.5
mostly size of neck
Eric Soileau
6.5
3.5
Buck #1 has full body and filled out hinds. Legs look short compared to body size. Full sagging belly. Buck #2 looks slender. Small hinds, and long legs make me think he is just starting to mature.
Anton J Pohl
4.5
2.5
1: Wide face structure, sagging posture, grey muzzle color
2: Thin face, long nose, upright posture
Al Jamieson
1.5
4.5
looks old
Mike Avery
3.5
1.5
reaction to other buck and tight neck and girth
Darren Meadows
3.5
2.5
Neither buck has swayback, the "roman nose", scars or ragged ears of an old buck. Both have nice antlers (by my standards), but neither appear to have other characteristics of an older deer.
Max
4.5
5.5
Body shape for each area of the country
Kevin salladin
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 has slight sagging in back. Buck 2 most bucks in NY dont make it to old age
Bill farmer
4.5
2.5
1st deer was showing maturity in the neck with wrinkles also the brisket was somewhat protruding the antlers were showing mass from top to bottom a slight pot belly.
2cnd lacks but shows some maturit
Dan Yonke
4.5
3.5
#1 long face. Lacks Roman nose.
#2. Looks young. Thin but tall rack.
BOYD
4.5
2.5
1st buck has a slightly sagging back & hanging brisket.
2nd buck has straight back, not very filled out physically and tighter brisket.
Lauri Thorn
5.5
3.5
Just a guess.
Andy Batka
3.5
2.5
Private land played a role into my guesses, as well as types of feed available in the locations of the deer.
Paul Gilberti
8.5
6.5
Shoulders wide, stance.
Mark Rosko
4.5
3.5
Buck #1, no chest drooping yet, big body but that’s Canada deer!
Dennis Michs
6.5
3.5
For Canada he may be on his way down. Really dark antlers. Roman nose..gray face. Ny buck looks like he hasn't reached his potential. Slim neck and body. Youthful face
Dale Goytowski
5.5
2.5
Buck 1 large fully developed body.
Buck 2 small body & light rack of a younger deer
Brian Stewart
4.5
3.5
Belly size
Adam Michels
4.5
3.5
Buck #1 has short face small sway in back and belly sags, legs seem small for body frame.
Buck #2 longer face and straight back and not much sag in belly legs and body are proportional.
Danny Long
6.5
4.5
#1 I judged by the sag in his mid section and same for #2
craig ettenhofer
7.5
4.5
# 1 Loose neck skin and barrel belly and just looks old. #2 body size, antlers and looks younger
Neil Hambrick
5.5
3.5
I used the WAG method.
Scott Cushing
4.5
3.5
Buck #1, no sway back, belly straight across. Buck #2, belly tips up towards the hind quarters.
Rick Moran
3.5
2.5
Size of their necks
Chris Juvinall
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 - heavy shoulder and some blading in rack.
Buck 2 - looks mature, but young to me.
Greg Brown
4.5
2.5
Based on body (chest) size
Gregory Hammell
4.5
3.5
Instinct
derek grothen
4.5
3.5
first one little sag in back and filled out. second one filled out but no sag.
thomas harvey
3.5
2.5
body shape
Eric Begalske
3.5
1.5
#1 Has a nice thick neck, strong solid looking body and the belly is starting to sag. #2 has a small body and tiny neck. It's not as filled out, stomach is straight lined.
Herb Higgins
7.5
4.5
Loose neck skin and barrel belly #1, bit of belly #2
Alan Lomasney
5.5
2.5
Buck 1 is thick in chest Gut slightly sagging, short legs,
Buck 2 has thin neck, longer legs, small head and thinner chest and body
David Wilson
6.5
2.5
Buck 1 is thick neck and body dominate posture interacting with other bucks. Saggy belly heavy rack. Buck 2 leaner but full body growing rack.
Ryan Hrabe
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 - Thicker body and slightly belly sag
Buck 2 - narrow body and no belly sag
keith
5.5
4.5
#1 bigger head - forehead/brow "bumps"
#2 smaller of the aforementioned
Jon Johnson
3.5
3.5
Straight backs, thin necks
Adam Nowak
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 has a big neck and the deer is just thick all around. Buck 2 definitely looks younger than Buck 1 does. Buck 2 is younger but looks to have better genetics than Buck 1.
Jake Allen
5.5
3.5
Neck / brisket waddle on #1 puts him greater than a 4.5 yo, so 5.5 yo. #2 doesn't have a "gut", so 3.5 yo.
Mike
4.5
3.5
Buck#1 neck goes right in to chest, some what of a roman nose. Buck#2 neck doesn't go right in to chest and rump stick up higher then his body
Erik Ungewitter
4.5
3.5
buck 1 looks mature, but didn't seem to have the massive "roman" nose that the older ones up there have. Buck 2 is a beautiful NY buck. Looks like a solid 3.5 if I had to guess.
Matt Clarke
3.5
3.5
Those deer are the same age...build difference are due to location only...#2 may actually be older.
Bernie Weisgerber
5.5
3.5
buck one is getting gray and buck 2 just looks and acts young,antlers not heavy yet
Mitch Lincoln
4.5
2.5
Buck 1 filled out body especially neck/chest. Antlers have not fully achieved mass.
Buck 2 thin frame, both body and antlers.
JEREMY WILLIAMS
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 is clearly in charge and fully mature. Tough to say how old but for sure at least 5. Buck 2 you said was everywhere. Leads me to believe younger.
Joseph J McIntosh
5.5
4.5
both bucks look like about mature deer, but not excessively old. only reason for difference in age was belly on buck 1.
Adam Shook
4.5
2.5
1 is a solid frame deer with a larger and lower-hanging belly, the shorter snout and rounded face shows he is getting older and mature.
2 has the longer snout and flat belly, signs of a younger buck
Steven Presnal
3.5
6.5
Buck 1 is mature but probably needed another year or two to reach full potential. Buck 2 has the classic short tine length of an old deer and was showing up more often, typical as they get older
Justin vanek
4.5
7.5
Buck 1 - definitely a mature deer - pot belly - neck meet the chest pretty low
Buck 2 - another mature deer looks to be on the way down
Justin vanek
4.5
7.5
Buck 1 - definitely a mature deer - pot belly - neck meet the chest pretty low
Buck 2 - another mature deer looks to be on the way down
Gordon Roe
6.5
3.5
buck one body completely filled out and horns on decline. buck Two in prime but body not completely formed
Denny McKernan
4.5
5.5
Body size and location
Bradford King
5.5
3.5
Facial features........and body/bone structure....first deer is well proportioned and filled out completely but starting to show a little back/belly sag....second deer is filling out well but not ther
Gary Eichelberger
5.5
3.5
based on the belly sag and amount of grey on his face or lack of. Nice deer. I'm expecting a surprise or 2 with actual age.
Bill Martin
5.5
7.5
Buck one lacks the sway back of an older deer but is in his prime. On Buck 2 He has a little bit more of sunken appearance and will be heading downhill.
Melvin Tobin
4.5
4.5
Out west bucks grow bigger then ones south of the border but faces still look young
Kevin Tetee
3.5
3.5
Both deer are “long legged” lack a “heavy” front end and their necks don’t flow into the brisket
Brad Baillargeon
3.5
3.5
Both faces and bodies look young. Buck 1 looks like a young Canadian buck.
Doug harr
4.5
6.5
No one is slim waisted and no sag in back. No two is big for New York touch of sag to back but more of a guess than number one.
Joe Cugliat
6.5
3.5
Buck 1 has good tines and antler mass, while also having a deep body. Buck 2 has nice tines but not much antler mass and his body is not deep so he is not an older deer.
Ron Rockwell
6.5
3.5
Buck 1 is a mature buck with a hugh body so I assume heis older and also looks to be in his prime.
Buck 2 in velvet so body does not look as big as number 1 and he does not appear to be really old.
Daniel Miranian
5.5
3.5
1st buck has thick neck and is starting to get a potbelly but his back is not sagging yet. 2nd buck has underdeveloped neck that does not come down to the brisket
Ed Sample
4.5
2.5
Nate P
5.5
4.5
#1-belly size, not terribly old in the face
#2-slim belly, young face
Al Jones
5.5
3.5
Just Guessing
Jay VanConant
4.5
3.5
Buck one,
Minimal jowls
Neck to chest attachment height at bottom
Straight back
Fairly flat belly
Buck two
No Jowls
Neck does not go low on chest
Flat back and belly.
Robert Webster
4.5
3.5
First buck is mature but nit sway back or potbellied. 2nd buck is a great up and comer but does not look mature. I realize it is early and his neck will get bigger but just looks sleek and not mature.
Phil J
5.5
4.5
educated guess
Alan Jensen
5.5
6.5
????
Ralph Archer
3.5
2.5
Angle of back, legs proportion to body
Chuck Salerno
3.5
2.5
Going off body size. 2nd buck looks like summer time so could be misleading.
Bret Tiller
4.5
2.5
Buck one more mature. Buck 2 clean front and trim body. Buck 1 fuller front.
Kyle Young
4.5
3.5
No clue.. just guessing
MANUN KREIZEL
6.5
2.5
buck 1, has a belly and its back is has a bow in it. buck 2, has the looks of a young deer with good genes
Troy Westrum
3.5
7.5
W. A. G. Method
Based off of moon phases and TBM
rationale
Chas Catania
5.5
3.5
#1 is mature, won't shock me if he's 4.5 but I went 5.5 because of his pot belly and neck/brisket area. #2 is younger Best guess is 3.5 as he's slight in build for a mature deer, hasn't yet filled out
George Henry Quay
5.5
7.5
First thought was that buck one was 5.5+ , but then again it is Saskatchewan, where 4 year olds are hogs.
Second buck looks like he has lived a good, long life. Wild ass guess says 7.5.
Cory Smith
5.5
3.5
Buck 1: Deep chest, big bodied brute. First thought 4.5, but went 5.5.
Buck 2: Thinner features, straight back. 3.5
The differences in where these bucks live is huge.
Stuart Brittain
4.5
7.5
Buck 1 looks to be in his prime, buck 2 looks a little older due to body maybe slimming down, and just bias thinking bucks take a while to get to 10 points in NY.
Tom Lipko
2.5
3.5
both deer don't have the mass or width of older deer
Forest Keith
5.5
4.5
100% guess
Matt Smith
4.5
7.5
Buck 1 is mature but probably needed another year or two to reach full potential. Buck 2 has the classic short tine length of an old deer and was showing up more often, typical as they get older
scott
5.5
6.5
bellow size and face
ny doe snot grow em that big,,,deer has to be mature
Nicholas E Steger
4.5
3.5
I look at the chest shape & how big is his belly.
Joel Koning
4.5
3.5
Body size, antler thickness.
David McFarlin
4.5
5.5
Guessing
Dave Mitchell
5.5
3.5
Gus's based on body shapes
Tyler Ball
6.5
4.5
Buck 1. Neck connects low to chest, dominant behavior, little bit of a swayed back.
Buck2. Appears younger. No back sway, neck connects higher on chest.
Stephen Jaranson
4.5
3.5
I am looking at the nose and body's they don't look very old. In my part of the country these bucks would be older with racks that size, as we have mainly woods and swamps with no farm lands.
Ike Henry
6.5
3.5
Buck one has trash and seems to be fit - doesn't look like a buck that far into decline yet.
Buck two's antlers just appear to be almost to full potential for that part of the country.
Blake Younggren
4.5
3.5
Buck 2 is tough to tell being that it's still early and he has his summer hair and hasn't filled out yet.
JUSTIN BELL
3.5
5.5
Buck 1 looks like an Iowa buck. Buck 2 looks to be older an possibly on the verge his rack going down hill, big body.
Greg Simon
4.5
8.5
Very difficult to guess based on limited information. Just on body characteristics.
rodney michallas
3.5
2.5
#1 shoulders and hind quarters not thick. neck to chest suggests possible 4.5 but body does not.
buck # 2 ---thin all around
Dave Fabian
4.5
3.5
the NY buck i would have aged older but his neck size held me back,
SAC buck has genetics on his side but his points haven't reach full potential , really just a two big guesses
Deepcut
6.5
3.5
based on body
Kent Goodridge
6.5
5.5
Have no real experience just guessing
Ken Shaner
5.5
3.5
Deer 1 sagging belly and very thick neck.
Deer 2 thin neck and thin belly compared to number one
Kevin Bova
3.5
2.5
Deer up north look to be a little bigger ( neck belly etc) and fat as more woods more mature less pressure these might be the same age diff environment. NY buck is just not there yet
Jack Harris
4.5
3.5
Body characteristics. But no real way to tell for sure.
David W Binz
5.5
3.5
I just look at the bellies.
Oak Duke
3.5
3.5
Buck No. 1 from Saskatchewan, bigger race of deer. Bull neck, later photo, but not overly developed shoulders or squinty eyes. No. 2 earlier photo, still Sept., waist much smaller than chest .
rich j ludovina
5.5
4.5
guessing
Tom Henry
6.5
4.5
Buck number one is probably in his prime.
Buck number two was a couple years out of becoming a beast.
Loren McGarrahan
5.5
2.5
#1 depth of neck, meets brisket low on the chest. Fully developed shoulders. Lacks pot belly & sway-back of older buck.
#2 Thin neck, meeting high on chest. Undeveloped shoulders, light frame.
Loren McGarrahan
5.5
2.5
#1 depth of neck, meets brisket low on the chest. Fully developed shoulders. Lacks pot belly & sway-back of older buck.
#2 Thin neck, meeting high on chest. Undeveloped shoulders, light frame.
Seth Hussey
3.5
2.5
both shooters on MA public!
Jonathan Teater
4.5
4.5
based on body charateristics
Mike Wylie
5.5
3.5
#1 is a stud in his prime # 2 lacks the mass of an older buck
Dustin Hatchell
5.5
3.5
Buck one has a large neck and the other deer are skiddish of the buck.
Stephen DiMarino
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 I think is a little deceiving. The Sas whitetails are bigger. While he is big, in the video he didn't seem too old to me, wasn't stiff legged and doesn't appear to have a sway back.
Paul Merioles
6.5
3.5
Buck 1: Thick neck, sagging gut. Looks like a old, beginning to sag person.
Buck 2: Thin neck, looks athletic and fit.
James Fowler
4.5
3.5
experience
TIM RIGG
6.5
5.5
Guesses
Brian Westfall
3.5
4.5
Buck #1, thin neck, lean "race horse" looking body.
Buck #2, thick neck, that blends into the shoulder. Legs appear short for the body. No real hanging belly or sway back that would put him at 5.5.
Reid
3.5
6.5
New York, Velvet, Side Angle Night Pictures. A complete guess for a Midwest Hunter.
Curt DeHaan
4.5
3.5
Size of body, location, and lastly descriptions given.
JOHN HELGESTAD
4.5
3.5
Buck #1 Front quarters slightly larger than rear from profile but narrower from front. No significant sway back indicating older.
Buck #2 Front and rear quarters appear about the same.
Keith Callahan
3.5
5.5
Buck number 1 is from upper North and known to be bigger then that .
Buck number 2 is looking thin and starting to show ribs.
John Paczkowski
4.5
2.5
Though hefty, Buck #1 does not have the sagging belly, etc. that older bucks, and gents, tend to get.
Buck #2 is sleek and has yet to beef up. Still an up and comer.
Paul Natoli
5.5
6.5
Just guesses, I'll go out on a limb and say the 2nd deer is older than the first. NY compared to Sask. is tough.
Steve R Wieting
4.5
3.5
Just Guessing
MARK BECK
5.5
3.5
Buck one has neck of mature Buck two looks younger
Rick Normand
4.5
2.5
Bigger dropped belly on number one. Number two just has an undeveloped face to me
Matt Ross
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 has a solid body, thicker rack with kickers but no thick fur patch between antlers. Buck 2 looks younger bodied, thinner rack 3.5
Jonathan Dudley
4.5
3.5
Based solely on body build characteristics...
Buck #1 has a very thick girth and pronounced brisket.
Buck #2 is a smaller bodied deer, no real belly drag,.
Donnie Peterson
3.5
2.5
Physical appearance. Locale.
Tyler S Goodman
4.5
3.5
buck 1 - thick neck. broad front shoulders. neck meets chest at a low point.
buck 2 - Thin neck, thin shoulders, thin body. The summer time photos may be deceiving me though.
Bruce
3.5
5.5
Its a trick...so I switched the ages of what I actually thought
Norman Yoder
5.5
5.5
Horn ThickNESS
Robert Miller
4.5
6.5
rack an body
Norman Yoder
5.5
5.5
Horn ThickNESS
Jarrod Wood
4.5
3.5
The first buck had filled out more in the chest area and was starting to develop a belly. The second buck gave the appearance of a race horse, he appeared to be still developing his body.
Duane Redford
4.5
4.5
tight bellies, sloping noses, no gray, flat backs, decent racks
Thomas Levy
5.5
3.5
Gut feeling based on body size and location
Matt Schuyler
5.5
4.5
Complete guess! I suck at judging from photos. Actually......probably not that good at judging in real life either! Thanks for the game though.
peter j mcpherson
3.5
7.5
buck 1 does not have the classic roman nose of an older buck and deer are big in the north. Buck 2 is older and being from NY I think he is on the downward slide
Clint Mitchell
4.5
2.5
Horns
Peyton Donath
5.5
3.5
1 has a bigger slouched body and 2 has thinner body with not as big of rack
Peyton Donath
5.5
3.5
1 has a bigger slouched body and 2 has thinner body with not as big of rack
Donald Long
3.5
5.5
#1 Looks mature but doesn't appesr to have the huge body of 4+ yt old of Canadian deer.
#2 Video shows buck w big frame but hes not filled out yet like he would be in Oct/Nov
Blane Baker
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 is just a bruiser. Short legs, face, ears. Blocky body. Fat. Dewlap under chin
Buck 2 is younger. Long ears, long face. Not filled out. Sounds like he acted like a 3 year old too
Aaron Short
5.5
3.5
sway in the back and nose appearance.
Kelly Devine
5.5
4.5
Tried to explain but text was limited. pure guesses.
Jason Lankford
5.5
3.5
1st buck, blocky frame, fat rolls on neck, heavy in chest
2nd buck long lean has not filled out yet but beginning. Body is balanced front to back neck flows seamlessly to body
Craig McAlvey
5.5
3.5
Buck 1 has a solid filled out body. Buck 2 looks slim and not blocky.
Doug Gray
6.5
4.5
Just going by body size and structure.
Fred Adams
5.5
3.5
1. Sagging belly, neck looks huge compared to body. Legs look short.
2. Long legs, spindly rack.
Jack Rasmussen
5.5
3.5
Sask. buck is filled out whilst NY bucks don’t live past 3.5 due to liberal logic.
John Brandon
6.5
3.5
Buck 1 looks fully mature, sagging belly, buck 2 you must be tricking us but he looks young to me
Rupe
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 was much bigger in the body, buck #2 was just a guess as I wish there had been more video.
Paul Borgatti
4.5
3.5
Based on over all mass and head shape
Ryan Heneghan
4.5
3.5
Buck 1 legs proportional to his body, defined neck muscles, some stomach
Buck 2
Legs look smaller for body, smaller neck, back slopes toward shoulders
John Long
5.5
3.5
B1 - Grey face and pedicle base on the skull is well pronounced suggesting an older buck.
B2 - Lean body.
Ron deems
3.5
5.5
Nose shape
Michael T. Wheeler
6.5
3.5
Buck two from NY is much younger, thinner in the chest, neck and body.
Ron Lech
3.5
6.5
Guessing based on body and locale
John B Woodall III
4.5
4.5
Buck 1 has a nice split.
Buck 2 is hard, the velvet makes him look bigger than he really is
Kevin Martin
3.5
6.5
buck 1 looks filled out and compared to the 1 1/2 old didn't look way bigger and no sag to his back or belly. Also thought his face looked young. Buck 2 just looked more run down and aged
Bill Reynolds
5.5
3.5
Body shape and size.
Rick Holland
6.5
3.5
Buck #1 is definitely (my opinion) 6.5 years old. Sway back, pot belly, neckline running clear t the base of its chest.
Buck #2, is 3.5. He's got a straight back line with a neck isnt filled out.
Tom Uselding
4.5
3.5
Buck #2's body in not yet to prime or past his prime. This could be an old buck on his way out.
sean witthar
3.5
3.5
Just a WAG for free stuff
Tom McCaffery
4.5
7.5
No rationale just a wag
Justin M Howell
5.5
6.5
Just what I think
Jason Mucker
4.5
3.5
Belly sag & perception of leg length
John Cannon
3.5
5.5
W.A.G.
Shawn Leonard
3.5
5.5
1st deer still looks young, no sway back at all a lot of weight still in the ass end. Deer two, I am from NY and I know where your property is takes at least 4 years here for a buck to get that big!
Joe Simpson
4.5
2.5
based on body size
Jason Mitzel
4.5
3.5
Would be my guess for what the body’s look like
PATRICK KLINGENSMITH
3.5
5.5
looks to me to be the body shape and mass of a canadian buck would be at that age for buck #1. buck #2 looks like the 5.5 year olds we have running around in ohio during the summer.
Mark F Pedo
5.5
3.5
#1- body appears sticky and shorter legs.
#2 - thinner body, longer legs.
Brian Shanley
5.5
4.5
Neck size and antler growth
Stanley Shane
3.5
5.5
I put buck 2 older because of the width of his rack compared to the verticalness of buck 1
Barry Hughes
5.5
5.5
just a guess
Lawrence Jarvie
5.5
3.5
Base on belly sag and slight hump in the back
David Pasky
5.5
4.5
Just a guess
Mike Schmitt
5.5
2.5
.
Todd Jahn
4.5
4.5
Body size
Carl waggle
3.5
2.5
Buck 1 has heavy body of a mature deer. Might be even older but northern deer are large. Buck 2 is younger with a less mature body.
joe blow
3.5
1.5
rack and body
Ryan Philbrick
5.5
3.5
Looking at the bellies.
Micheal Dollendorf
5.5
3.5
body indicators led my decisions.
Jeff Valovich
5.5
3.5
Sagging belly on #1, full body and chest ....... #2 just looks to be young, not filled out
Jascha J Wood
5.5
3.5
Buck one has a deeper brisket. Buck two is young
Brian Mongeau
5.5
3.5
Buck 1, big body and from CN. Buck 2, mature but still young looking
Greg Frederick
4.5
4.5
Body structure in relation to location...or...just throwing darts.
Luke Weiland
4.5
5.5
Buck #1 I was going back and forth btween 4.5 and 5.5, but face made me lean toward 4.5... Buck #2 is absolutely difficult seeing it is early season and in an area of the country that I am unfamiliar.
Keith Latimer
5.5
3.5
Buck one has a big body and neck. Almost looks like he has short legs. He's mature.
Buck 2 is young, 3.5 tops. Slender body and pencil neck, and his legs look very long.
JAMES WILLEMS
3.5
3.5
#1 could be 4 1/2 but he had a young face. #2 Early season deer, especially in velvet are impossible to age. Not a good enough video to have more than a guess
BILL COLLINS
5.5
3.5
#1 I FEEL WOULD HAVE MORE OF A SAGGING JOWL, GUT HANGING MORE # 2 SMALL NECK SHOULDER FEATURES EQUAL FINE 3.5 YEAR
MARCO PINQUE
3.5
3.5
The lack of a real belly leads me to believe they are both 3.5
roger mcgarry
3.5
6.5
just a guess
James Franklin Stone
4.5
2.5
buck 1 has fuller face , th icker body and a dropping stomach.
Buck 2 has a young doe thin face with a trim built and no stomach
daniel campbell
4.5
5.5
just a guess
Tim Schroeck
4.5
3.5
Buck #2 - Thin antlers, not wide bases, not a large belly, longer looking legs
Buck #1 - good belly, good brisket. Not large bases but has stickers
Steve Niedzielski
3.5
2.5
Saskatchewan buck- Heany in shoulders, cylindrical body...seems to lack the heavier facial structure of a typical 4 year old. NY buck, just looks like a 2 year old. Skinny, light horned, chest is same
Joe Hrbacek
3.5
5.5
Purely a guess
Brian Vogelgesang
5.5
2.5
Big thick body on the first buck.
Conner Updike
4.5
6.5
Educated guess. Lmao!!!
Steve Marod
4.5
5.5
Buck #1 has a young face and the antlers appear not as heavy. Buck #2 is from out east and just seems older with the long nose/face.
Scott Fritz
5.5
6.5
It's how I feel.
Arnie Camford
4.5
5.5
Buck 1 is OK for Saskatchewan, Buck 2 is is fantastic for NY.
Instructions
Buck 1
Buck 2
Your Guess
Analytics
Results
