Carbon Express Arrows
Safety Harness Test for Bowhunters

Test designed and performed by Bowsite.com

 

About the Bowsite.com Treestand Harness Test

Four years ago we tested two of the top treestand safety harnesses using a 'real-world' test by deliberately falling from a treestand and evaluating the design. Technology innovations, new companies, along with product improvements prompted us to do it again. In 2009 we contacted several companies for inclusion in this test. Most of them responded and provided us with a harness. These manufacturers include Summit SOP, Hunter Safety Systems, Muddy Outdoors, and Mountaineer Sports. New this year, we also asked our forum visitors to provide the criteria that was important to them in a safety harness. From that list we came up with the following evaluation criteria (not in order):

  • Ease of use
  • Attachment to the tree
  • Ability to stop the fall
  • Comfort while hanging
  • Flexibility with hunting clothing
  • Compactness & Weight/Bulk
  • Interference with the shot

We broke the tests into 3 parts:

Part 1 - Review of Each Harness including features, design, ease of use
Part 2 - Risk-free controlled descent to gauge the comfort while hanging and determine whether we wanted to perform Part 3 - the actual fall test
Part 3 - Actual fall from a 12' treestand with no additional safety measures

Disclosure - Summit SOP is a Bowsite.com Platinum sponsor. We assure you that we evaluated all products fairly and objectively based on the criteria above.

How we conducted each test - we used criteria forms to evaluate each harness and all product was left in its original packaging until the actual test took place on June 14, 2009. We skimmed the instructions (which is what we believe most people would do) and we put each vest on to gauge how intuitive the harness is for the hunter to figure out. After the evaluations in Part 1 we performed a controlled descent off of a ladder to give us a risk-free hang test. We are particular sensitive to simply jumping from the tree like we did in our last evaluation. If I was comfortable with the controlled descent in Part II, then I would go ahead and do an actual fall in Part III. Three out of four vests made the cut. We filmed every controlled descent and every fall test just one time using both a fixed camera on the ground as well as a small Point of View (POV) cam which was strapped to each vest to film the experience from my angle. Those videos are included in this feature.


Please Read
- These tests are subjective and based on my own experience using these products. Your experience could vary based on the features important to you, your body type and weight, how you configured the vest and many other factors. I would like to make this clear that you are reading my opinion based on what I experienced. Do not try this test at home! Serious injury or death could occur if you deliberately attempt to fall from a treestand. It is our opinion that any vest (even the ones that did not test well) are far better than no vest at all. Always wear your safety harness as soon as your feet leave the ground.


Treestand Harness Test Results

Discuss this feature on the Bowsite.com Forums

  • Sitka Gear